Bad Santa Gift Ideas: The Art of Giving Terribly (on Purpose)

santa smoking and with tatoos

Welcome to the chaotic, passive-aggressive, laugh-until-you-cry world of Bad Santa gift exchanges—where the goal isn’t to give something good, it’s to give something gloriously awful. At GiftGivingSucks.com, we’ve long held the belief that most gifts are performative nonsense. But Bad Santa? Bad Santa is a rare moment of honesty. It’s the one time of year when you’re supposed to give something terrible—and we are so here for it.

So whether you’re prepping for a Dirty Santa showdown, a White Elephant war zone, or a Yankee Swap with your most sarcastic coworkers, we’ve got the ultimate list of Bad Santa gift ideas that will make people laugh, cringe, and maybe question your friendship. Let’s unwrap the madness.

Table of Contents

What Is a Bad Santa Gift Exchange?

If you’re new to the concept, here’s the gist: everyone brings a wrapped gift—usually something funny, weird, or borderline offensive. People take turns choosing a gift or stealing one that’s already been opened. The more ridiculous the gift, the more it gets stolen. The goal? Chaos. Laughter. And ideally, someone walking away with a singing fish plaque they didn’t ask for.

Bad Santa is not about sentiment. It’s about spectacle. It’s about watching your boss unwrap a toilet-themed coffee mug and pretend to love it. It’s about giving a gift so confusing, so unnecessary, that it becomes legendary.

The Golden Rules of Bad Santa Gifting

Before we dive into the list, let’s lay down some ground rules:

  1. Funny beats functional. If it’s useful, it’s probably boring.
  2. Weird is wonderful. The more niche and inexplicable, the better.
  3. Cheap is chic. Most Bad Santa exchanges have a price cap—usually $10–$25. Embrace the budget.
  4. Wrap it like it’s worth a million bucks. The more beautiful the packaging, the more devastating the reveal.

Now, let’s get to the good stuff.

Top 20 Bad Santa Gift Ideas That Will Ruin Friendships (In a Fun Way)

1. Toilet Golf Set

Because nothing says “I care” like encouraging someone to work on their short game while they’re on the throne.

2. Screaming Goat Figurine

Push the button. Hear the scream. Question your life choices.

3. “Emergency Underpants” in a Tin

Practical? Maybe. Embarrassing to open in front of coworkers? Absolutely.

4. A Nicolas Cage Sequin Pillow

Stroke it one way: a normal pillow. Stroke it the other: full Cage face. Nightmares included.

5. A Candle That Smells Like Regret

Yes, that’s the actual scent. No, we don’t know what it smells like. Probably your ex.

6. A Mug That Says “World’s Okayest Employee”

Perfect for the office party where HR is watching.

7. A Taxidermy Squirrel Doing Yoga

It’s art. It’s trauma. It’s unforgettable.

8. A Burrito Blanket

Wrap yourself in carbs. Emotionally and literally.

9. A Book of Useless Facts

Because nothing says “I didn’t know what to get you” like trivia about wombat poop.

10. A Giant Flask That Holds an Entire Bottle of Wine

Subtle? No. Effective? Also no. Hilarious? Always.

11. A Bag of Reindeer Poop (a.k.a. Chocolate-Covered Raisins)

For the person who’s been just naughty enough.

12. A Bob Ross Chia Pet

Happy little accidents, now in plant form.

13. A “Grow Your Own Boyfriend” Kit

Just add water and lower your standards.

14. A Calendar of Awkward Family Photos

Twelve months of secondhand embarrassment.

15. A Soap That Looks Like a Stick of Butter

Watch someone try to cook with it. Then watch them cry.

16. A Puzzle of a Plain Beige Wall

500 pieces. All the same color. For the masochist in your life.

17. A “Nothing” Box

Literally a box labeled “Nothing.” It’s the thought that doesn’t count.

18. A Chicken Nugget Keychain

Because who doesn’t want to carry around a fake nugget?

19. A “Bathroom Guest Book”

Let your guests rate their restroom experience. Five stars for the air freshener.

20. A Life-Sized Cutout of Danny DeVito

No explanation needed. Just vibes.

Bad Santa Gift Keywords to Know (and Abuse)

If you’re shopping online or trying to optimize your own gag gift blog post (we see you, SEO nerds), here are some Bad Santa gift keywords to keep in mind:

Use these to find the worst (read: best) gifts the internet has to offer—or to make sure your own terrible gift guide gets the attention it deserves.

What Not to Bring to a Bad Santa Exchange

Let’s be clear: there’s a difference between “bad” and “boring.” Don’t be the person who brings:

  • A $5 Starbucks gift card (yawn)
  • A scented candle that actually smells good (save it for your mom)
  • A generic mug with no punchline (try harder)
  • A pair of socks (unless they have Nicolas Cage’s face on them)
  • Anything that says “Live, Laugh, Love” unironically

Bad Santa is not the time for safe bets. It’s the time for chaos, confusion, and cackling.

How to Win Bad Santa (Yes, It’s a Competition)

Want your gift to be the one everyone fights over? Here’s how to win:

  1. Go for the laugh. If it makes people snort eggnog out their nose, you’ve nailed it.
  2. Be unexpected. The weirder, the better.
  3. Wrap it like it’s luxury. Nothing builds suspense like a Tiffany-blue box that contains a rubber chicken.
  4. Know your audience. If it’s a work party, keep it PG-13. If it’s your college friends, all bets are off.

The Gift Wrap Up

Bad Santa isn’t just a game—it’s a gift-giving revolution. It’s a glorious rejection of the pressure to be thoughtful, sentimental, or even remotely appropriate. It’s a reminder that sometimes, the best gift is the worst one.

So this year, skip the scented candles and the gift cards. Embrace the absurd. Wrap up a Nicolas Cage pillow. Give someone a puzzle that will ruin their weekend. Be the reason someone laughs so hard they cry.

Because at GiftGivingSucks.com, we believe the best gifts don’t come from the heart—they come from the clearance aisle of a novelty store and a deep, unhinged commitment to the bit.

Renee Cavvy
Renee Cavvy

Renee brings over 30 years of gift giving experience to holidays, birthdays, anniversaries, weddings, workplace and faith events. Every life moment is cause for celebration or those times in life when we need the "the gift of support". Her mission: Let's all be better in appreciating one another, put an end to meaningless gifts that clutter our lives, and give from a place of love and kindness. This midwest mom (and grandma) offers novel and creative ideas to do gift giving better!

Related Posts